suman-nachir tatka gan

[niladribagchi]

Nabbaier dasake 'sumaner ganer' abirvaber pray sathe sathei ek buk agun nie ganer jogote peyechilam r ek nakhyatrok-srijukto nachiketa chakraborty.Sumanda r nachiketa ganer dui dhara bohon koren(jibonmukhi akhya jodio dujoner ganei legeche).

Sumaner gane amra peyechi adhunik sabdo,jontranusonger byabohare avinabatya,sampurno 'brand new' presentation r sob theke boro manush sumaner gan sune abar bangla gank sunte suru korlen.

Nachida kichu eke bare 'rolling stone' dhache ese bollen 'ei besh valo achi'.tanr gane khub sahaj bisoy ro sahaj vabe upostahpito holo,kokhono kokhono khub kathin bisoyo onar lekhonir choyay ekebare ontorer kore tuleche,jemon 'bridhasrom'.

Sumaner jodi 'tomak chai' ek notun premer jonmo deyo,notun angik khule deu,nachir 'nilanjana' tobe buker vitorer ekebare satti kothatak khub sahaj vabe samne nie ase.

jantranusange ba presentation o lyrice suman nachir thekie soto alokborso egie,kintu gayokir dhong ba surer(onek sur paschatyo ba dakhini sangeeter onukorone,se onekei kore thaken) baichitre nachir carishma ache.lyriceo kichu khetre nachi atyar atyio hoe othe.Bisesh kore bangali apamor jubo samajer kache nachir ekta alada appeal chilo o ache.

sumaner bagmita,bisoyer govire probesh,bivinyo emotione ganer choyon jemon slaghar dabi rakhe,temni nachir sorolote,ganer vitor eke bare juba samajer addar vasa proyog korao kichu khetre prosongsar dabi rakhe.

Suman nachir tatka gane bangali samaj upokrito hoyeche.ei threade onader parosporik mullayan hok na ektu.

[agang]

Originally Posted by niladribagchi

Nabbaier dasake 'sumaner ganer' abirvaber pray sathe sathei ek buk agun nie ganer jogote peyechilam r ek nakhyatrok-srijukto nachiketa chakraborty.Sumanda r nachiketa ganer dui dhara bohon koren(jibonmukhi akhya jodio dujoner ganei legeche).

Sumaner gane amra peyechi adhunik sabdo,jontranusonger byabohare avinabatya,sampurno 'brand new' presentation r sob theke boro manush sumaner gan sune abar bangla gank sunte suru korlen.

Nachida kichu eke bare 'rolling stone' dhache ese bollen 'ei besh valo achi'.tanr gane khub sahaj bisoy ro sahaj vabe upostahpito holo,kokhono kokhono khub kathin bisoyo onar lekhonir choyay ekebare ontorer kore tuleche,jemon 'bridhasrom'.

Sumaner jodi 'tomak chai' ek notun premer jonmo deyo,notun angik khule deu,nachir 'nilanjana' tobe buker vitorer ekebare satti kothatak khub sahaj vabe samne nie ase.

jantranusange ba presentation o lyrice suman nachir thekie soto alokborso egie,kintu gayokir dhong ba surer(onek sur paschatyo ba dakhini sangeeter onukorone,se onekei kore thaken) baichitre nachir carishma ache.lyriceo kichu khetre nachi atyar atyio hoe othe.Bisesh kore bangali apamor jubo samajer kache nachir ekta alada appeal chilo o ache.

sumaner bagmita,bisoyer govire probesh,bivinyo emotione ganer choyon jemon slaghar dabi rakhe,temni nachir sorolote,ganer vitor eke bare juba samajer addar vasa proyog korao kichu khetre prosongsar dabi rakhe.

Suman nachir tatka gane bangali samaj upokrito hoyeche.ei threade onader parosporik mullayan hok na ektu.

amaar mone hoy na suman aar nochiketa ei duti naam ek sange miliye deoa sangoto.

anirban

[niladribagchi]

Originally Posted by agang

amaar mone hoy na suman aar nochiketa ei duti naam ek sange miliye deoa sangoto.

anirban

Thik ki karone dujoner sampork ek sathe alochona hote pare na jante pari ki?

[kashibhatta]

aamaar mone hoy, sangato baa asangato ei proshno noy, niladri jaa bolte cheyechhen, ei dujaner gaan aabaar baangaalike baanglaa gaaner dike kaan pheraate baadhyo korechhilo.
suman-er sange sei arthe kono naam-i ki tulaneeyo? aamaar mone hoy naa. kintu sejanyo onnyo kaauke niye aalochonaa hotei paarbe naa, emon-o ki haoyaa uchit?
'bheer kore imaarat aakaashtaa dheke diye churi kore niye jaay bikeler sonaa rod/ chhoto chhoto shishuder shaishab churi kore granthokeet-er dal baanaay nirbodh' kimbaa, "hoyto kaarur buke maathaa rekhe/dirghashwaas haasimukhe dekhe/niraapattaar ushnotaa diye dhaakle jantronaa" ei kathaagulo ekebaarei aalochonaar ajogyo?
sedin chaitromaas-e suman taahole nachi-r kholaa galaa-i baa kaaje laagaaalen keno? kimbaa, 'chhoto baro mile' album-e, "hajmi khele hajom habe ei bhebe keu hajmi khaay?"
aasole oi samay tinjan tin dik diye dhorlen. suman taanr lyrics-e aanklen onnyo chhobi. nachir bhakto tairi holo, ektu 'rough & tough' gharaanaay, jaanraa bollo, "hajaar kabitaa bekaar sab-i taa", aar anjan-er adbhut parjobekshan, "nonaa deoyaal theke, jishu chhalchal chokhe, haat tule aashwaas dey, ekhono".
ei abodaan asweekaar korle ki thik korbo? jaani naa, satyi.

[niladribagchi]

Originally Posted by kashibhatta

aamaar mone hoy, sangato baa asangato ei proshno noy, niladri jaa bolte cheyechhen, ei dujaner gaan aabaar baangaalike baanglaa gaaner dike kaan pheraate baadhyo korechhilo.
suman-er sange sei arthe kono naam-i ki tulaneeyo? aamaar mone hoy naa. kintu sejanyo onnyo kaauke niye aalochonaa hotei paarbe naa, emon-o ki haoyaa uchit?
'bheer kore imaarat aakaashtaa dheke diye churi kore niye jaay bikeler sonaa rod/ chhoto chhoto shishuder shaishab churi kore granthokeet-er dal baanaay nirbodh' kimbaa, "hoyto kaarur buke maathaa rekhe/dirghashwaas haasimukhe dekhe/niraapattaar ushnotaa diye dhaakle jantronaa" ei kathaagulo ekebaarei aalochonaar ajogyo?
sedin chaitromaas-e suman taahole nachi-r kholaa galaa-i baa kaaje laagaaalen keno? kimbaa, 'chhoto baro mile' album-e, "hajmi khele hajom habe ei bhebe keu hajmi khaay?"
aasole oi samay tinjan tin dik diye dhorlen. suman taanr lyrics-e aanklen onnyo chhobi. nachir bhakto tairi holo, ektu 'rough & tough' gharaanaay, jaanraa bollo, "hajaar kabitaa bekaar sab-i taa", aar anjan-er adbhut parjobekshan, "nonaa deoyaal theke, jishu chhalchal chokhe, haat tule aashwaas dey, ekhono".
ei abodaan asweekaar korle ki thik korbo? jaani naa, satyi.

khub satty kotha kashi da.sei sfulingok aswikar korar kono obokas nei.tai alochona hole khub valo lagbe.

[agang]

Originally Posted by niladribagchi

Thik ki karone dujoner sampork ek sathe alochona hote pare na jante pari ki?

dujon ke niye ek saathe alochona korte gele dujoner modhye kicchhu mil thaka dorkar....aamar mone hoi suman aar nochiketa-r moddhe temon kono mil nei...dujon-e eki somoye bangla gaaner jogote eshechhen eituku chhaRA.
sei arthe aaro onekei to eshhechen...shudhu anjan keno - pratul mukhopadhyay, tapan sinha, pallab kitrania, moushumi bhowmik, eto gulo band...aabaar onnodike lopamudra, indranil, srikanta, rupankar...aaro aneke...kintu suman-er songe eNder sobari duratta anekkhani...pratibhar deek theke...era sobai nishchoy guni shilpi, bangla gaane ender abodan onoshikarjo...tobe aamaar mone hoi era keui sumaner somokokkho non...eta aamaar obhimot

theek ei karonei mone hoy suman/rabindranath, rabindranath/jeebonanando, satyajit/ritwik, dylan/cohen dharoner alochona khub ekta arthobaho noy

aar ekta kotha, suman nochiketa ke diye gaan koriyechhen, er theke ki praman holo? suman-er sure to indranil sen-o geyechhen...aamar mone hoi indranil sen-er gaoa 'tumi gaan gaile' gaanti sunlei bujhben sudhu galay sur thaklei gaan gaoa jaay na...gaan gaite hole gaaner mormokatha bujhte hoi

amake bhool bujhben naa...onno kono shilpikei chhoto korchhi na...nochiketa, moushumi, anjan sabaike niyei alochona hok, ei forum-ei hok, tobe ta bangla gaan-er bibartaner brihattaro poriprekhhite...'suman nachi-r tatka gaan'er modhe je prachhonno tulana royechhe...setatei kebol aabaar apatti

anirban

[niladribagchi]

apni thik bolechen bondhu dujon puro dui ghoranar.kintu jodi bangla gan 90er dosoke manush sunte suru koren tobe seta ei dui joner jonyei.pore onyoder nam asbe.(sakaler proti sradhya niyei bolchi).
kabir o nachketa k besi guni seta niye bitorker obokash thakei ontoto amar mote.nachiketar 'nilanjana-1' hoyto sahityiker mullayaone 'tomak chai' noy kintu 'nilanjana'r kotha gulo onek saral vabe koisorer mohok tule dhoreche.nachir vasay sorolotar sathe dhar ache.sei sorolota makhano dhark ograhya koratao uchit noy.sumaner gan tanr lyric ek onek adhunik ,tanr gane amra mohit,tobu nachik ba anjank vule jaoar karon nei.bakider nam ami bollam na ei karonei muloto ei 3 jon besi alochito.tobe tanrao mei threade swagoto.'parosparik mullayan' bolte ekhane tulona chaichi na,dujon durokom style gan koren,puro vinyo sei nie gothon mulok alochona chichi.

[arijit]

I dont want to compare between Suman & Nachiketa as because both of them have got its individual style.There are some brilliant compositions of Nachiketa also.But overall Kabir is more poetic & very bold in his expression.

[arijit]

Originally Posted by niladribagchi

Nabbaier dasake 'sumaner ganer' abirvaber pray sathe sathei ek buk agun nie ganer jogote peyechilam r ek nakhyatrok-srijukto nachiketa chakraborty.Sumanda r nachiketa ganer dui dhara bohon koren(jibonmukhi akhya jodio dujoner ganei legeche).

Sumaner gane amra peyechi adhunik sabdo,jontranusonger byabohare avinabatya,sampurno 'brand new' presentation r sob theke boro manush sumaner gan sune abar bangla gank sunte suru korlen.

Nachida kichu eke bare 'rolling stone' dhache ese bollen 'ei besh valo achi'.tanr gane khub sahaj bisoy ro sahaj vabe upostahpito holo,kokhono kokhono khub kathin bisoyo onar lekhonir choyay ekebare ontorer kore tuleche,jemon 'bridhasrom'.

Sumaner jodi 'tomak chai' ek notun premer jonmo deyo,notun angik khule deu,nachir 'nilanjana' tobe buker vitorer ekebare satti kothatak khub sahaj vabe samne nie ase.

jantranusange ba presentation o lyrice suman nachir thekie soto alokborso egie,kintu gayokir dhong ba surer(onek sur paschatyo ba dakhini sangeeter onukorone,se onekei kore thaken) baichitre nachir carishma ache.lyriceo kichu khetre nachi atyar atyio hoe othe.Bisesh kore bangali apamor jubo samajer kache nachir ekta alada appeal chilo o ache.

sumaner bagmita,bisoyer govire probesh,bivinyo emotione ganer choyon jemon slaghar dabi rakhe,temni nachir sorolote,ganer vitor eke bare juba samajer addar vasa proyog korao kichu khetre prosongsar dabi rakhe.

Suman nachir tatka gane bangali samaj upokrito hoyeche.ei threade onader parosporik mullayan hok na ektu.

Nachiketa has got some brilliant composition but overall Suman is more poetic & very bold in his expression.

[kolkata]

e katha ashikarjya je 90 dasak e jadi bangali janata hindi gaan er moho tyag kore bangla ganer proti akrishta hoye pore,ja adate bala bahulya banglar manush hoyechilo,se khetre suman o nachiketa ebang kichu matray anjan er dabi samarthan jogyo.kintu ekta katha bolte kono dwidha hoyto amar mone nei je suman (sama ukti ager ekta post e o porlam)poetic brilliance hoyto kaeksho alokbarsha agiye(sachetan bhabe kabir bandana na korei bolchi).du ekta bhalo composition chara amar mone hoy na nachiketar gaan serokom bhabe manush ke bhabiyechi.bola jetei pare at the most tar gangulo manush ke ,kichu flashy swabdo chayan er madhyame ek seconder er 'masti 'diyeche kintu ta konodin e bhabna ,chinta,bishleshaner rasad jogayni.barong bhabte adbhut lage pratul er mato shilpi ke keno manush sei bhabe explore korlen na..pratul er ganer poetic brillliance ,tar ganer natakiyata anek er mato amakeo mugdhya koreche,kintu ta konodin e ekta sizeable audiencer kache grahanjogyo hoye otheni.........................forum er bondhu ra ei niye tader ki matamot janaben.....bhalo thakben sakkole....